|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 41-45
A split face comparative study of safety and efficacy of microneedling with tranexamic acid versus microneedling with Vitamin C in the treatment of melasma
Ashok Menon, Hafsa Eram, Prashanth R Kamath, Saumya Goel, Amita Murali Babu
Department of Dermatology, Venerology and Leprosy, A.J Institute of Medical Sciences, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
|Date of Web Publication||13-Jan-2020|
Department of Dermatology, Venerology and Leprosy, A.J. Institute of Medical Sciences, Mangalore - 575 004, Karnataka
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Introduction: Melasma is a common pigmentary disorder affecting the face. Although a few risk factors have been identified, the exact pathogenesis remains elusive. Many treatment modalities have been tried, but none have been completely successful. Aim: To compare safety and efficacy of microneedling with Tranexamic acid versus microneedling with Vitamin C in the treatment of melasma. Materials and Methods: It was a split face, comparative study conducted on 30 female melasma patients. After obtaining informed consent, microneedling with Tranexamic acid was done on left side and microneedling with Vitamin C was done on right side of face. The improvement was evaluated on the basis of clinical photographs, MASI, Physician Global Assessment (PGA) and Patient Global Assessment (PtGA) at each visit (0, 4 and 8 weeks). Z test was used to test the significant difference in the means of the 2 groups at 4 weeks and at 8 weeks. Results: At the end of 8 weeks, MASI, PGA and PtGA showed improvement with both tranexamic acid and vitamin C. However the improvement was more with tranexamic acid than with vitamin C, although not statistically significant. Conclusion: Both TXA and Vitamin C are effective and safe treatments for melasma. But, TXA was found to be more effective.
Keywords: Melasma, microneedling, tranexamic acid, treatment, Vitamin C
|How to cite this article:|
Menon A, Eram H, Kamath PR, Goel S, Babu AM. A split face comparative study of safety and efficacy of microneedling with tranexamic acid versus microneedling with Vitamin C in the treatment of melasma. Indian Dermatol Online J 2020;11:41-5
|How to cite this URL:|
Menon A, Eram H, Kamath PR, Goel S, Babu AM. A split face comparative study of safety and efficacy of microneedling with tranexamic acid versus microneedling with Vitamin C in the treatment of melasma. Indian Dermatol Online J [serial online] 2020 [cited 2022 Jan 23];11:41-5. Available from: https://www.idoj.in/text.asp?2020/11/1/41/261220
| Introduction|| |
Melasma is a common pigmentary disorder that affects mostly women. Its prevalence ranges from 1.5% to 33.3%., It is characterised by symmetric hyperpigmented macules affecting the malar region, forehead, and temples.
The exact pathogenesis and cause of melasma are still unknown. Various risk factors have been postulated to cause melasma including pregnancy, drugs, OCPs, exposure to sunlight, etc.
Based on how deep the melanin pigment is, melasma is classified as epidermal, dermal, and mixed.
Various treatment options have been evaluated in the treatment of melasma, but none have been found to be satisfactory and the effect is typically short-lived.
Tranexamic acid (TXA) is an antifibrinolytic drug, which is being used as a depigmenting agent. It can be given either orally, topically, intradermally, or intravenously.
In humans, Vitamin C is the most abundant antioxidant. In addition, it has photoprotective, antiaging, and antipigmentary properties. However, it penetrates the skin poorly which can be overcome using various methods, such as ultrasound, iontophoresis, microdermabrasion, etc.,,
In this split face study, we compared microneedling with TXA and microneedling with Vitamin C in the treatment of melasma.
| Materials and Methods|| |
A split face comparative study was done after the approval from the Institutional Ethics Committee.
Informed written consent was obtained from 30 patients belonging to the age group 18–55 years with bilaterally symmetrical melasma before enrolling them in the study.
Patients on oral contraceptive pills or hormone replacement therapy, pregnant women and lactating mothers, patients with any systemic illness or endocrinological disease, history of bleeding disorders, drug allergy, patients having a keloidal tendency and active infection at the local site were excluded from this study.
Personal and medical history was obtained and clinical examination was done.
Melasma area severity index (MASI) was developed by Kimbrough-Green et al. for the assessment of melasma. The severity of the melasma in the four regions (forehead, right malar region, left malar region, and chin) is assessed based on: percentage of the total area involved (A), darkness (D), and homogeneity (H).
The numerical value assigned for the corresponding percentage area involved is as follows: 0 = no involvement; 1 = <10% involvement; 2 = 10 − 29% involvement; 3 = 30 − 49% involvement; 4 = 50 − 69% involvement; 5 = 70 − 89% involvement; and 6 = 90 − 100% involvement. The darkness of the melasma (D) is graded as: 0 = normal skin color without evidence of hyperpigmentation; 1 = barely visible hyperpigmentation; 2 = mild hyperpigmentation; 3 = moderate hyperpigmentation; and 4 = severe hyperpigmentation. Homogeneity of the hyperpigmentation (H) is graded as: 0 = normal skin color without evidence of hyperpigmentation; 1 = specks of involvement; 2 = small patchy areas of involvement <1.5-cm diameter; 3 = patches of involvement >2-cm diameter; and 4 = uniform skin involvement without any clear areas).
Total MASI score: forehead 0.3 (D+H) A + right malar 0.3 (D+H) A + left malar 0.3 (D+H) A + chin 0.1 (D+H) A.
The affected malar area was cleaned, and topical EMLA was applied for 45 mins.
TXA is available as a 500 mg/5 ml ampoule. About 1 ml of TXA is drawn in a 2-ml syringe and diluted with 1-ml normal saline to get a concentration of 50 mg/ml of TXA.
The skin was stretched, and microneedling done in vertical, horizontal, and diagonal directions. The dermaroller had 192 microneedles made of medical-grade stainless steel with a width of 2 cm, needle length of 1.5 mm, and diameter of 0.25 mm. In total, 1 ml TXA (4 mg/ml) was applied on the left side and 20% Vitamin C
was applied on the right side of the face, and the procedure was repeated. At the end of the procedure, ice packs were applied over the treated areas. Post procedure, patients were advised strict photo-protection.
The procedures were done two times at monthly intervals (0 and 4 weeks). Improvement was assessed with clinical photographs, MASI scoring, physician global assessment (PGA), and patient global assessment (PtGA) at each visit and any adverse effects were noted.
The assessment of improvement was graded as follows:
No improvement/mild response 0 − 25% improvement
Moderate response 25 − 50% improvement
Good response 50 − 75% improvement
Very good response >75% improvement
Z test was used to test the significant difference in the means of the 2 groups at 4 weeks and 8 weeks.
| Results|| |
Out of 30 patients in the study, all were females and 13 (43.4%) were in the age group 35 − 39 years [Table 1]. The average duration of melasma was 3.73 ± 1.65 years. In total, 17 (56.7%) patients had Fitzpatrick skin type 5 and 13 (43.4%) patients had type 4. Family history was positive in only 11 (36.7%) patients. Other risk factors such as history of use of oral contraceptive pills was present in 10 (33.3%) patients and a history of thyroid disease was present in 8 (26.7%) patients. The average duration of solar exposure per day in hours was 2.87 ± 2.23. Demographic and clinical data have been summarised in [Table 2].
All patients had undertaken various types of topical treatments in the past. All 30 patients enrolled in the study completed the study.
The average baseline MASI (MASIb) was 8.93 ± 1.65, which showed 8.9% improvement to 8.2 ± 1.56 with TXA and 3.7% improvement to 8.6 ± 1.42 with Vitamin C at 4 weeks. At the end of 8 weeks, it showed 20.5% improvement to 7.1 ± 1.53 with TXA and 12.3% improvement to 7.83 ± 1.46 with Vitamin C [Table 3]. The total MASI reduced from 268 at baseline to 246 with TXA and 258 with Vitamin C at the end of 4 weeks. At the end of 8 weeks, it further reduced to 213 with TXA and 235 with Vitamin C [Figure 1].
The P value for MASI at 4 and 8 weeks for both TXA and Vitamin C was >0.05, implying that though there was a difference, it wasn't significant [Table 3].
Most patients showed moderate improvement with TXA, whereas with Vitamin C most of them showed only a mild improvement. According to PGA, at the end of 8 weeks, 3 (10%) patients showed good improvement with TXA, and only 1 (3.33%) with Vitamin C. Patient satisfaction with treatment was higher with TXA, with 56.7% showing moderate improvement, in contrast with only 16.7% showing moderate improvement with Vitamin C. Improvement in PGA and PtGA are shown in [Table 4] and [Figure 2], [Figure 3].
Clinical improvement is seen in the photographs [Figure 4], [Figure 5], [Figure 6], [Figure 7].
|Figure 4: (a) Patient A with centrofacial melasma at 0 weeks before the initiation of treatment. (b) Patient A with centrofacial melasma showing improvement at 8 weeks after 2 sessions of microneedling with Vitamin C|
Click here to view
|Figure 5: (a) Patient A with centrofacial melasma at 0 weeks before the initiation of treatment. (b) Patient A with centrofacial melasma showing improvement at 8 weeks after 2 sessions of microneedling with TXA|
Click here to view
|Figure 6: (a) Patient B with centrofacial melasma at 0 weeks before the initiation of treatment. (b) Patient B with centrofacial melasma showing improvement at 8 weeks after 2 sessions of microneedling with Vitamin C|
Click here to view
|Figure 7: (a) Patient B with centrofacial melasma at 0 weeks before the initiation of treatment. (b) Patient B with centrofacial melasma showing improvement at 8 weeks after 2 sessions of microneedling with TXA|
Click here to view
No serious adverse effects were noticed. Out of 30 patients, only 10 (33.3%) complained of mild itching and burning sensation, which resolved spontaneously.
| Discussion|| |
TXA (trans-4-aminomethyl cyclohexane carboxylic acid) is an antifibrinolytic agent which blocks lysine-binding sites on plasminogen molecules. It is also being used as a depigmenting agent. In a study by Lee et al., MASI showed a significant reduction at the end of treatment following weekly intradermal injection of TXA. A study conducted by Budamakuntla et al. showed better improvement in melasma patients treated with microneedling with TXA compared to microinjections with TXA, though it wasn't statistically significant.
Improvement of melasma after microneedling was reported in one case series., Microneedling induces matrix metalloproteinases which are thought to reduce the hyperpigmentation.
A significant improvement in pigmentation was observed in a study which examined the role of Vitamin C and a chemical penetration enhancer in the treatment of melasma. In a split face study by Ustuner et al., microneedling with Vitamin C following Q switched Nd:Yag laser therapy for melasma showed a better clinical response than Q switched Nd: Yag laser therapy alone.
In this study, we did a split face comparison to assess the safety and efficacy of microneedling with TXA and microneedling with Vitamin C in the treatment of melasma. Improvement was assessed on the basis of clinical photographs, MASI, PGA, and PtGA. There was a reduction in MASI, PGA, and PtGA over the 3 visits; the maximum improvement was seen on the 8th week. Improvement with TXA was better than with Vitamin C, though not significant. This is probably because TXA inhibits melanocyte activation by UV light, melanocyte proliferation induced by hormones, neovascularization under the influence of VEGF, and basement membrane damage caused by mast cells. No serious adverse effects were noted.
| Conclusion|| |
Microneedling is an easy and simple office procedure that ensures the uniform delivery of the medication by creating microchannels. Microneedling with both TXA and Vitamin C is a safe and effective treatment for melasma. In our study, we found the improvement to be more with TXA. However, the result wasn't statistically significant due to a small sample size. TXA acts at various levels of melanogenesis in melasma, and hence is a promising therapeutic agent. However, further studies with a larger sample size are required to identify the ideal agent, formulation, and duration of therapy to treat melasma effectively.
Declaration of patient consent
The authors certify that they have obtained all appropriate patient consent forms. In the form the patient(s) has/have given his/her/their consent for his/her/their images and other clinical information to be reported in the journal. The patients understand that their names and initials will not be published and due efforts will be made to conceal their identity, but anonymity cannot be guaranteed.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Budamakuntla L, Loganathan E, Suresh D, Shanmugam S, Dongare A, Prabhu N, et al
. A randomised, open-label, comparative study of tranexamic acid microinjections and tranexamic acid with microneedling in patients with melasma. J Cutan Aesthet Surg 2013;6:139-43.
] [Full text]
Pichardo R, Vallejos Q, Feldman S, Schulz M, Verma A, Quandt S, et al
. The prevalence of melasma and its association with quality of life in adult male Latino migrant workers. Int J Dermatol 2009;48:22-6.
Werlinger K, Guevara IL, González CM, Rincón ET, Caetano R, Haley RW, et al
. Prevalence of self-diagnosed melasma among premenopausal Latino women in dallas and fort worth, tex. Arch Dermatol 2007;143:424-5.
Grimes P. Melasma: Etiologic and therapeutic considerations. Arch Dermatol 1995;131:1453-7.
Victor F, Gelber J, Rao B. Melasma: A review. J Cutan Med Surg 2004;8:97-102.
George A. Tranexamic acid: An emerging depigmenting agent. Pigment Int 2016;3:66-71. [Full text]
Manela-Azulay M, Bagatin E. Cosmeceuticals vitamins. Clin Dermatol 2009;27:469-74.
Telang P. Vitamin C in dermatology. Indian Dermatol Online J 2013;4:143-6.
] [Full text]
Lee W, Shen S, Wang K, Hu C, Fang J. Lasers and microdermabrasion enhance and control topical delivery of vitamin C. J Invest Dermatol 2003;121:1118-25.
Ebihara M, Akiyama M, Ohnishi Y, Tajima S, Komata K, Mitsui Y. Iontophoresis promotes percutaneous absorption of l-ascorbic acid in rat skin. J Dermat Sci 2003;32:217-22.
Kimbrough-Green C, Griffiths CE, Finkel LJ, Hamilton TA, Bulengo-Ransby SM, Ellis CN, et al
. Topical retinoic acid (Tretinoin) for melasma in black patients. Arch Dermatol 1994;130:727-33.
Dunn C, Goa K. Tranexamic Acid: A review of its use in surgery and other indications. Drugs 1999;57:1005-32.
Lee J, Park J, Lim S, Kim J, Ahn K, Kim M, et al
. Localized intradermal microinjection of tranexamic acid for treatment of melasma in Asian patients: A preliminary clinical trial. Dermatol Surg 2006;32:626-31.
Cohen B, Elbuluk N. Microneedling in skin of color: A review of uses and efficacy. J Am Acad Dermatol 2016;74:348-55.
Lima E. Microneedling in facial recalcitrant melasma: Report of a series of 22 cases. An Bras Dermatol 2015;90:919-21.
Liebl H, Kloth L. Skin cell proliferation stimulated by microneedles. J Am Coll Clin Wound Spec 2012;4:2-6.
Hwang S, Oh D, Lee D, Kim J, Park S. Clinical efficacy of 25% l-ascorbic acid (C'ensil) in the treatment of melasma. J Cutan Med Surg 2009;13:74-81.
Ustuner P, Balevi A, Ozdemir M. A split-face, investigator-blinded comparative study on the efficacy and safety of Q-switched Nd:YAG laser plus microneedling with vitamin C versus Q-switched Nd:YAG laser for the treatment of recalcitrant melasma. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2017;19:383-90.
Tse T, Hui E. Tranexamic acid: An important adjuvant in the treatment of melasma. J Cosmet Dermatol 2013;12:57-66.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4], [Figure 5], [Figure 6], [Figure 7]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]
|This article has been cited by|
Comparison of the efficacy and safety of intralesional injection of tranexamic acid and the topical application of
combination drug in the treatment of macular amyloidosis
| ||Mohammadreza Ghassemi, Masoumeh Roohaninasab, Seyed Abolfazl Kamani, Afsaneh Sadeghzadeh-Bazargan, Azadeh Goodarzi |
| ||Dermatologic Therapy. 2022; 35(1) |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Efficacy and Safety of tranexamic acid versus vitamin c after microneedling in treatment of melasma: Clinical and Dermoscopic study
| ||Yasmina El Attar, Noha Doghaim, Nashwa El Far, Samar El hedody, Soha Abdalla Hawwam |
| ||Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology. 2021; |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Applications of microneedling for various dermatologic indications with a special focus on pigmentary disorders: A comprehensive review study
| ||Elham Ziaeifar, Fatemeh Ziaeifar, Samaneh Mozafarpoor, Azadeh Goodarzi |
| ||Dermatologic Therapy. 2021; 34(6) |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||COMPARATIVE EVALUATION OF MICRONEEDLING WITH MESO SOLUTION VERSUS MICRONEEDLING ALONE IN TREATMENT OF RECALCITRANT MELASMA: A SPLIT FACE STUDY.
| ||Pooja Pooja, Tejinder Kaur, Suresh Malhotra |
| ||INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH. 2021; : 12 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||ESTUDO COMPARATIVO DA EFICÁCIA DE TRATAMENTOS PARA O MELASMA: KLIGMAN E CYSTEAMINE
| ||Lara Dayane de Medeiros Leite, Milena Alves de Sousa, Livio Vasconcelos do Egypto |
| ||Revista interdisciplinar em saúde. 2020; 7(Único): 1131 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|